Page 2 of 3

Re: Technical Versus Fundamental Analysis

Posted: Fri Jun 04, 2021 10:17 pm
by lightndark
Jakethetrader wrote: Mon May 31, 2021 8:58 pm Because I believe, only by combining the two can we understand why price bounced off a support level. Or if a breakout from the resistance level was indeed valid and backed by the fundamentals justifying the move.
Agreed buddy!
Fundamental and technical analysis are really very useful in forex trading.

Re: Technical Versus Fundamental Analysis

Posted: Tue Sep 14, 2021 2:36 pm
by Swiss_cheese
Technical is my favorite, but you certainly can't ignore the fundamentals! Then there is sentiment too. The three legs of the stool!

Re: Technical Versus Fundamental Analysis

Posted: Tue Sep 14, 2021 2:37 pm
by Swiss_cheese
Technical is my favorite, but you certainly can't ignore the fundamentals! Then there is sentiment too. The three legs of the stool!

Re: Technical Versus Fundamental Analysis

Posted: Mon Oct 18, 2021 7:18 am
by momo3HC
I was, am and always will be a TA fan.

Re: Technical Versus Fundamental Analysis

Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2021 10:49 pm
by sebking1986
I think you need a foot in both camps to understand the WHY.

Re: Technical Versus Fundamental Analysis

Posted: Thu Jan 27, 2022 3:33 am
by mlawson71
I think both work, but if one focuses on one only they have to have at least a passing understanding of the other too.

Re: Technical Versus Fundamental Analysis

Posted: Thu Jan 27, 2022 3:55 am
by Intrest 1
bilbao wrote: Tue Apr 25, 2017 4:13 am Technical Versus Fundamental Analysis

Like other financial markets, the forex market has two primary methods of performing market research that traders can then use to base their trading decisions on. These are:

Technical analysis - Relies solely on historical price action and computed indicators to forecast future exchange rates. Besides price action, a number of other related indicators such as oscillators, volume and moving averages are typically used in technical analysis. Technical analysis can be very helpful for calling short term price movements and for timing market entry and exit points.

Fundamental analysis - Consists of reviewing the economic and political reasons behind currency moves. Often involves interpreting the micro and macro economic indicators for the currency's nation in order to determine the relative value of the currency versus another currency. Fundamental analysis can be better for forecasting longer term exchange rate moves.

Basically, both forms of analysis can provide ample opportunities for traders to profit from trading forex. Analysis is a tool, and when placed in the right hands and used in moderation, will generally enhance trading profits and opportunities.

Pros and Cons of Technical Analysis

While some fundamental analysts liken technical analysis to reading tea leaves or palms, technical analysis provides one of the best and most objective tools available for quickly and accurately assessing a market and then trading it profitably.

One of the potential benefits of technical trading consists of the fact that the same data is also being watched by millions of other traders.

This phenomenon can lead to a herd effect in some cases when classic chart patterns can be clearly observed. In essence, the many traders who see the pattern and trade accordingly can help the pattern's measured move materialize.

Nevertheless, the disadvantage of this is that like minded technical traders tend to position their stops at the same levels. This could magnify a decline or prompt a stronger rally, and might even allow large players to intentionally trigger such stops which they can reasonably anticipate based on their own reading of the charts.

Pros and Cons of Fundamental Analysis

Fundamental analysis in the forex market typically involves taking into account basic economic and political factors for one country relative to another. These factors might include the following:

  • Measures of overall economic strength like growth and employment rates
  • Interest rates and investment yields
  • Trade and current account balances
  • Political stability

Fundamental forecasts for exchange rates are typically most useful for longer term time frames and not so much for short term trading. Nevertheless, some fundamental trading strategies have been developed that operate during the volatile period that often immediately follows important economic data releases.

Some traders prefer technical analysis and take issue with fundamental analysis on the basis that:

  • Its information is largely already priced into the market
  • It is time consuming and complicated to perform
  • It often requires an economics background
  • It does not give objective trading signals

Risk Statement: Trading Foreign Exchange on margin carries a high level of risk and may not be suitable for all investors. The possibility exists that you could lose more than your initial deposit. The high degree of leverage can work against you as well as for you.
"Nevertheless, the disadvantage of this is that like minded technical traders tend to position their stops at the same levels. This could magnify a decline or prompt a stronger rally, and might even allow large players to intentionally trigger such stops which they can reasonably anticipate based on their own reading of the charts."

This is a common misconception for inexperienced players.
For where there is a stop loss, there is always leverage, and leverage is not transactions, these are bets on volatility in the exchange game, which differs from exchange trading precisely in the presence of leverage.
Market makers don't care about someone's five-cent stops, because he has other tasks in the market.
The market maker does not even know about the existence of these stop-loss trades

Re: Technical Versus Fundamental Analysis

Posted: Sat Mar 05, 2022 3:16 pm
by MoneyMaker
Intrest 1 wrote: Thu Jan 27, 2022 3:55 am "Nevertheless, the disadvantage of this is that like minded technical traders tend to position their stops at the same levels. This could magnify a decline or prompt a stronger rally, and might even allow large players to intentionally trigger such stops which they can reasonably anticipate based on their own reading of the charts."

This is a common misconception for inexperienced players.
For where there is a stop loss, there is always leverage, and leverage is not transactions, these are bets on volatility in the exchange game, which differs from exchange trading precisely in the presence of leverage.
Market makers don't care about someone's five-cent stops, because he has other tasks in the market.
The market maker does not even know about the existence of these stop-loss trades
Quite an informative reply!

Re: Technical Versus Fundamental Analysis

Posted: Sat Mar 05, 2022 6:42 pm
by RplusT
You mean a US anti health institution......And they all point at Russia and China to divert attention from their evil deeds. The US Military got 22 labs for "research" at home only. Not talk about those abroad. Financed by the tax payers of course. So why would the military do scientific research and experiments, especially as they got death and destruction as their goal! Once asked, they stated they are just doing research concerning soldiers, like "researching brain cells and affect of chemical substances on them". Go figure!

Re: Technical Versus Fundamental Analysis

Posted: Mon Apr 17, 2023 2:30 pm
by 太虚一毫
Intrest 1 wrote: Thu Jan 27, 2022 3:55 am "Nevertheless, the disadvantage of this is that like minded technical traders tend to position their stops at the same levels. This could magnify a decline or prompt a stronger rally, and might even allow large players to intentionally trigger such stops which they can reasonably anticipate based on their own reading of the charts."

This is a common misconception for inexperienced players.
For where there is a stop loss, there is always leverage, and leverage is not transactions, these are bets on volatility in the exchange game, which differs from exchange trading precisely in the presence of leverage.
Market makers don't care about someone's five-cent stops, because he has other tasks in the market.
The market maker does not even know about the existence of these stop-loss trades
Technical analysis and fundamental analysis are not a question of pros and cons, but a question of "whether it is reliable".